At a time when a new crisis of confidence is shaking the banking industry, it is vital to get back to analyzing the fundamentals and noting the structural differences between the various sector players, Philip Adler writes in an essay for finews.first.


This article has been published on finews.first, a forum for authors specializing in economic and financial topics.


Universal banks serve a diverse customer base, offering the full range of basic financial services. Those services, which include loans, require banks to hold a large amount of capital in reserve. Universal banks often raise that money in the capital markets, with all the risks that imply.

The role of pure-play private banks, meanwhile, is to protect and grow their clients’ assets over the long term. Accordingly, they mainly serve wealthy individuals whose primary concern is to preserve their wealth and pass it on to future generations. This requires sophisticated asset management and wealth engineering services, which include lending but to a lesser extent.

Private banks’ lending mainly consists of Lombard loans – secured against clients’ financial asset portfolios – which are an alternative to traditional loans and naturally complement banks’ asset management activities. Some private banks also sometimes grant mortgages to help clients buy real estate as part of their overall wealth strategy.

«These ratios were introduced after the 2008 crisis»

By their nature, then, private banks provide services that require less capital, and they make little use of capital markets. In Switzerland, private banks hold larger amounts of capital, giving them a substantial base as measured by two key regulatory ratios: the LCR (liquidity coverage ratio) and the NSFR (net stable funding ratio). These ratios were introduced after the 2008 crisis by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, and their purpose is to assess a bank’s liquidity risk, i.e. its ability to fulfill its financial obligations, if it loses money on its investments, sees a large-scale withdrawal of deposits or is unable to convert its assets into cash.

The LCR measures a bank’s ability to meet its obligations within a 30-day timeframe. A bank must have an LCR of at least 100 percent, i.e. its commitments to be at least 100 percent covered by liquid assets. The NSFR came into force in the EU and Switzerland in 2021. It is intended to ensure the stability of a bank’s funding over the long term, and must also be at least 100 percent.

«This might have prevented Silicon Valley Bank from being struck down by a liquidity crisis»

European and Swiss banks, whatever their size and whatever their business activities, must meet these minimum ratios, which provide a guarantee that the bank is healthily managing its cash. While the LCR and NSFR ratios of universal banks tend to be close to the minimum of 100 percent, private banks generally have higher ratios because of their business model’s specific characteristics. Among Geneva private banks, for example, LCR ratios are around 200 percent.

In the US, however, after the Trump administration rolled back some requirements of the Dodd-Frank Act, banks with less than $250 billion worth of assets no longer had to comply with certain rules, including those relating to minimum LCR and NSFR levels. If the scope of application of those rules had not been restricted, warning signs might have arisen regarding Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) – which had $209 billion of assets – and this might have prevented it from being struck down by a liquidity crisis on 10 March 2023.

«The case of Credit Suisse was different»

Its collapse was the result of poor asset-liability management. It had invested most of its liquidity in medium- and long-term US Treasuries without hedging its interest-rate risk, and when rates rose this led to unrealized losses. Meanwhile, SVB’s liabilities consisted of deposits with shorter maturities than those of government bonds: this would not have been possible if the aforementioned minimum ratios had been applied. When accounting rules forced the bank to charge its unrealized losses against its capital, its financial solidity was called into question. Depositors lost trust and decided to withdraw their money en masse. SVB was unable to cope with all the withdrawals, prompting the US authorities to step in.

The case of Credit Suisse was different. Its fate was also sealed by a crisis of confidence, but the chain of events was very different because its capital ratios were sound. Its failure stemmed from a build-up of bad news arising from the bank’s involvement in various scandals and losses resulting from its inadequate risk management and its business model. The shockwave caused by SVB’s failure merely worsened the lack of trust in Credit Suisse, which was already well established, resulting in a bank run that proved fatal for Switzerland’s second-largest bank.

«This feature of Swiss private banks is founded on a certainty born from experience»

It is hard to imagine a similar disaster befalling pure-play Swiss private banks. They manage their cash conservatively, in particular by holding large amounts of money with central banks, and most importantly they are not involved in complex transactions of the kind undertaken by the investment banking divisions of universal banks. Their underlying risks and balance sheets are therefore easier to understand. This feature of Swiss private banks is founded on a certainty born from experience: no asset is more valuable than clients’ trust.


Philip Adler is the Global Head of Treasury & Trading at Geneva-based Union Bancaire Privée.


Previous contributions: Rudi BogniPeter KurerRolf BanzDieter RuloffWerner VogtWalter WittmannAlfred MettlerRobert HolzachCraig MurrayDavid ZollingerArthur BolligerBeat KappelerChris RoweStefan GerlachMarc LussyNuno Fernandes, Richard EggerMaurice PedergnanaMarco BargelSteve HankeUrs Schoettli, Ursula FinsterwaldStefan Kreuzkamp, Oliver BussmannMichael Benz, Albert SteckMartin Dahinden, Thomas FedierAlfred MettlerBrigitte StrebelMirjam Staub-BisangNicolas RothThorsten PolleitKim IskyanStephen DoverDenise Kenyon-RouvinezChristian DreyerKinan Khadam-Al-JameRobert HemmiAnton AffentrangerYves Mirabaud, Katharina BartFrédéric PappHans-Martin KrausGerard GuerdatMario BassiStephen ThariyanDan SteinbockRino BoriniBert FlossbachMichael HasenstabGuido SchillingWerner E. RutschDorte Bech VizardAdriano B. LucatelliKatharina BartMaya BhandariJean TiroleHans Jakob RothMarco MartinelliThomas SutterTom KingWerner PeyerThomas KupferPeter KurerArturo BrisFrederic PappJames SymeDennis Larsen, Bernd Kramer, Armin JansNicolas RothHans Ulrich JostPatrick HungerFabrizio QuirighettiClaire ShawPeter FanconiAlex Wolf, Dan Steinbock, Patrick ScheurleSandro OcchilupoWill BallardNicholas YeoClaude-Alain Margelisch, Jean-François HirschelJens Pongratz, Samuel GerberPhilipp WeckherlinAnne RichardsAntoni TrenchevBenoit BarbereauPascal R. BersierShaul LifshitzKlaus BreinerAna BotínMartin GilbertJesper KollIngo RauserCarlo CapaulMarkus WinklerKonrad HummlerThomas SteinemannChristina BoeckGuillaume CompeyronMiro Zivkovic, Alexander F. WagnerEric HeymannChristoph SaxFelix BremJochen MoebertJacques-Aurélien MarcireauUrsula FinsterwaldMichel Longhini, Stefan BlumZsolt KohalmiKarin M. KlossekNicolas RameletSøren BjønnessGilles PrinceSalman AhmedPeter van der WelleKen OrchardChristian GastJeffrey Bohn, Juergen BraunsteinJeff VoegeliFiona Frick, Stefan Schneider, Matthias HunnAndreas Vetsch, Fabiana Fedeli,  Kim Fournais, Carole MilletSwetha RamachandranThomas StuckiNeil ShearingTom Naratil, Oliver Berger, Robert SharpsTobias MuellerFlorian WickiJean KellerNiels Lan DokyKarin M. KlossekJohnny El HachemJudith BasadKatharina BartThorsten Polleit, Peter SchmidKaram HindujaZsolt Kohalmi, Raphaël SurberSantosh Brivio, Mark UrquhartOlivier Kessler, Bruno CaponePeter Hody, Michael BornhaeusserAgnieszka Walorska, Thomas MuellerEbrahim Attarzadeh, Marcel HostettlerHui ZhangMichael BornhaeusserReto JauchAngela AgostiniGuy de BlonayTatjana Greil CastroJean-Baptiste BerthonMarc Saint John WebbDietrich GoenemeyerMobeen TahirDidier Saint-GeorgesSerge TabachnikVega IbanezDavid Folkerts-LandauAndreas ItaMichael WeltiMihkel VitsurFabrizio PaganiRoman BalzanTodd SaligmanChristian KaelinStuart DunbarCarina SchaurteBirte Orth-FreeseGun WooLamara von AlbertiniPhilip AdlerRamon VogtAndrea HoffmannNiccolò GarzelliDarren WilliamsBenjamin BöhnerMike JudithJared CookHenk GrootveldRoman GausNicolas FallerAnna StünziThomas Höhne-SparborthFabrizio PaganiGuy de BlonayJan BoudewijnsBeat WittmannSean HagertyAlina DonetsSébastien GalyRoman von AhFernando FernándezGeorg von WyssStefan BannwartAndreas BrittFrédéric LerouxNick PlatjouwRolando GrandiPhilipp KaupkeGérard PiaskoBrad SlingerlendDieter WermuthGrégoire BordierThomas SignerBrigitte Kaps, Gianluca GerosaChristine HoustonManuel Romera RoblesFabian KäslinClaudia KraazMarco HuwilerLukas ZihlmannNadège Lesueur-PèneSherif MamdouhHarald PreisslerTaimur HyatPhilipp CottierAndreas HerrmannCamille VialMarcus HüttingerRalph EbertSerge BeckAlannah BeerStéphane MonierAshley SimmonsLars JaegerHa DuongClaude BaumannAndrew IsbesterShanna Strauss-FrankTeodoro CoccaBertrand Binggeli, Marionna WegensteinGeorge Muzinich, Jian Shi CortesiRazan NasserNicolas Forest, Joerg Ruetschi, Reto Jauch, Bernardo Brunschwiler, Charles-Henry Monchau, and Florin Baeriswyl.