Swiss banks surprise even the Bain experts

Competition in Swiss retail banking is intensifying. Digital providers such as Revolut, Yuh and Neon are attracting customers, while established banks are facing high costs, complex structures and rising technological demands. Yet traditional institutions do not have to hide when it comes to customer satisfaction.

That is shown by a new study by management consultancy Bain & Company, whose findings are available to finews ahead of publication. For the "NPS Prism" study, conducted for the first time in Switzerland, 1,700 retail customers were surveyed and a total of ~3,200 assessments of banking relationships were evaluated. Twelve traditional and digital banks were examined.

The results even surprised the study's authors.

Traditional banks surprisingly strong

"What is different from other countries," says Bain partner Dirk Vater in an interview with finews, "is the strong position of traditional Swiss banks." While digital institutions in other markets often lead the pack in customer satisfaction, in Switzerland traditional and digital providers alternate at the top of the rankings.

The study measures willingness to recommend using the so-called Relationship Net Promoter Score (rNPS). This indicates how likely customers are to recommend their bank to friends or family members, thereby providing insight into customer satisfaction.

The average across the banking relationships analyzed is 33 points. The range runs from minus 4 to plus 52 points.

A digital bank leads the field with 52 points. However, a traditional bank is already in second place with 47 points, followed by another digital bank with 46 points. The two business models also alternate in the next positions.

Bain
Jan-Peter Böttcher and Dirk Vater from Bain & Company. (Image: provided)

Particularly noteworthy: Two traditional institutions score 47 and 43 points respectively, putting them among the top group.

While the average is comparable to other European markets, Vater describes the results for traditional branch banks as exceptionally strong by international standards.

The names of the individual banks are not assigned to the respective point scores in the published comparison chart.

Digital banks have no automatic advantage

For Jan-Peter Böttcher, a partner at Bain & Company in Zurich and a specialist in retail banking, the results disprove a widespread assumption.

"Customer satisfaction is not, by definition, a question of the business model," he explains in an interview with finews.

What matters more, he says, is how consistently a bank aligns its services with customer needs.

At the same time, the results show that not all digital banks are actually able to translate their structural advantages into above-average customer satisfaction. Some digital providers score just 27 or 25 points, putting them below the average of the banking relationships analyzed.

Vater sees this as a warning sign. In theory, digital banks should have particularly good conditions for meeting customer expectations thanks to their lean and simply structured offerings.

Böttcher suggests one possible explanation, however, is that digital institutions are also increasingly offering broader and more complex product ranges. The more they evolve toward universal banks, the harder it may become to preserve the original simplicity of their business model.

Fees cause the most frustration

The study also shows why bank customers are dissatisfied.

With a share of 25 percent, fees and prices are the most frequently cited criticism among customers who would not recommend their bank. This is followed by customer service at 14 percent and missing or insufficient features at 10 percent.

It is not solely about the absolute level of fees.

"Not necessarily the absolute amount" is the key point of criticism, Böttcher explains. More often, customers are bothered by a lack of transparency and unexpected additional costs.

Traditional banks in particular face a challenge here. They may score points with personal advice and a broad range of services, but they also have to explain clearly to customers what they are paying for.

Among satisfied customers, the picture is different: good customer service, attractive features and straightforward use are highlighted most often.

Personal advice remains a competitive advantage

Another finding of the study is likely to please established banks.

Although banking is increasingly handled digitally, personal customer service remains one of the most important factors for a positive recommendation.

While digital banks often impress with user-friendly apps, attractive conditions and innovative features, traditional institutions can score especially well with advice, reliability and reputation.

For Böttcher, this contains an important strategic insight: established banks should not simply try to copy the offerings of their digital competitors. Instead, they need to further strengthen their own advantages and at the same time eliminate weaknesses in the digital customer experience.

Pure imitation of successful digital bank offerings is therefore hardly the right answer to mounting competitive pressure.

Banking apps perform significantly better than websites

The study further breaks down the rNPS into its key drivers: customer experience, product & price, and brand & reputation. Clear differences are especially visible in satisfaction with channel offerings.

Across all banks analyzed, mobile banking apps achieve a Net Promoter Score of 41 points. Websites, by contrast, score only 28 points.

Digital providers are particularly strong in mobile applications. However, traditional banks also receive good ratings.

Personal channels allow for much stronger differentiation. While advisory quality matters in branches, availability and problem-solving drive satisfaction in contact centers. 

The study's authors conclude: banking is becoming increasingly digital, but it is precisely personal support, high-quality products, simple processes and transparent costs that are among the strongest factors linked to customer satisfaction 

Satisfied customers are more valuable economically

For Bain, however, customer satisfaction is not just a matter of image. It also has direct economic effects.

The consultancy points to international benchmark data showing that particularly satisfied customers typically use twice as many products, have five times lower churn risk, make recommendations three times as often and generate ten times fewer support requests.

For banks, this creates a financial incentive to invest specifically in improving customer relationships.

Competition is likely to intensify

According to the two Bain partners, the fact that traditional Swiss banks are currently performing well does not mean they can rest on their strengths.

International digital banks have so far in some cases not addressed the Swiss market with the same consistency as other countries. With additional investment and greater adaptation of their offerings to local needs, this could change.

Böttcher sees gaps at some international providers in Swiss-specific functions, for example. If these are closed, their competitive position is likely to improve.