"Katastrophe" for Deutsche Bank and for journalism

Tuesday began with Deutsche Bank shares falling as much as 6.2 percent. Two whistleblowers had copied more than 15 million internal documents and passed them to journalists: emails, meeting minutes, compliance files and chat logs (finews.ch reported, in German).

At the center of it all is CEO Christian Sewing. The man who took over in 2018 to make the scandal-ridden bank a little more boring allegedly pushed internally for more risk, railed against compliance and kept problems from shareholders. On top of that come a planned expansion of the Russia business in 2020 and 2021, suspicious payments of $582 million linked to Jeffrey Epstein, and the accidental disclosure of Donald Trump's tax statements in 2017.

"Catastrophe" in his own words

The bank pushes back: The events date back many years, some of them two decades, and were discussed with supervisors at the time. Between 2019 and 2025, it says, it invested 7 billion euros in controls. It is a different bank today.

There is no shortage of embarrassing material. Profanity in emails. A Sewing who summed up a client due diligence debacle in 2018 with a single word: "Catastrophe." Analysts who were allegedly fed questions for conference calls. None of it is flattering. But is it a scandal?

A script in episodes

What stands out above all is the staging. More than 200 journalists from around 70 media organizations analyzed the data, coordinated by the South African non-profit Barracuda Media. Among them are the Financial Times, Der Spiegel, Le Monde and the New York Times.

In Switzerland, the Tages-Anzeiger handles the local angle. It describes Deutsche Bank Switzerland as a favored address for Russian oligarchs, from Suleiman Kerimov and Viktor Vekselberg to Alisher Usmanov and Mikhail Fridman (article in German, paywall). Of all people, Switzerland removed the latter two from its sanctions list just under two weeks ago (finews.ch reported, in German).

Publication was synchronized and intoxicated by its own superlatives: The Tages-Anzeiger calls it the "biggest data leak in history." Further installments are announced for this week, on Qatar, Colombia and Aldi. Dramaturgy worthy of Shakespeare.

The pack on the hunt

It is fair to speak of a pack mentality. Some 70 of the world's largest media organizations have joined forces in a crusade. They share the material, the angle and the timing. Anyone looking for a dissenting reading will look in vain.

No power on earth can stand up to such a front. No crisis PR, no legal department, no statement however carefully worded. The bank can send out as many statements as it likes. The verdict is in before anyone has read the first sentence of the rebuttal. Who is supposed to correct a story when everyone tells it the same way at the same time?

Déjà vu from Panama

The pattern is familiar. In April 2016, the journalist network ICIJ published the Panama Papers, 11.5 million documents from the law firm Mossack Fonseca. The driving forces back then were Süddeutsche Zeitung journalists Bastian Obermayer and Frederik Obermaier. Today they run Paper Trail Media, and their names also appear on the Deutsche Bank investigation.

And what came of it in criminal terms? Iceland's Prime Minister Sigmundur Davíð Gunnlaugsson resigned but was never charged. Pakistan's head of government Nawaz Sharif was sentenced to ten years in prison in 2018 in the London property affair. In 2023, the High Court in Islamabad overturned the verdict and acquitted him.

Acquitted across the board

The main protagonists also walked free. In June 2024, a court in Panama acquitted all 28 defendants (in German), including the law firm's co-founder Jürgen Mossack. The chain of custody for the evidence could not be established. As early as 2022, Mossack, his partner and 37 other people had been acquitted in a separate money laundering case.

What remains are back taxes and a handful of criminal tax convictions against individuals, for example in the U.S. The first taxpayer convicted there was an 83-year-old businessman. For the biggest data leak of its time, decorated with a Pulitzer Prize, that is a meager record.

The damage remains

The reputational damage, by contrast, was lasting. It hit not only Panama but every offshore financial center, Switzerland included. Local banks, lawyers and fiduciaries were pilloried for months for having set up companies for clients. In the vast majority of cases, that was perfectly legal. Acquittals years later no longer make headlines.

Herein lies the fundamental problem: Anyone who casts structures the average reader doesn't understand as inherently close to criminality is engaging in scandalization, not enlightenment.

A high bar for stolen data

Journalism based on stolen data is not illegitimate per se. But it requires a high threshold. It is justified where it documents serious wrongdoing – ideally criminal – that would otherwise remain hidden. It must spare bystanders, and the willingness to do so does not appear particularly pronounced.

Measured against that standard, little remains of the Deutsche Bank investigation so far. The Epstein relationship has been known for years and settled with $225 million in fines and settlements. The $582 million from Epstein's orbit stem from suspicious activity reports that the bank itself filed with U.S. authorities in 2019 – exactly as the law requires. Suspicious activity reports are leads, not evidence.

A Kremlin list is not a sanctions list

The Russia business is a similar story. Yes, the bank still wanted to grow in 2020 and 2021 despite concerns from its own compliance staff, as did other financial institutions. But the clients on the so-called U.S. Kremlin list were not sanctioned, as the FT itself notes. The business was mainly booked in Switzerland. After Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the bank pulled out. Doing business with clients who were not sanctioned at the time is not an offense but the result of a strategy and a risk assessment – one that can certainly be debated in hindsight.

That leaves the Trump case. In 2017, a relationship manager sent the tax statements of 1,586 private banking accounts to the accountant of a single client, including accounts belonging to Trump. The accountant deleted the file and reported the error. The bank informed the New York Fed but not the affected clients. That is what the journalists are now holding against it.

The irony could hardly be greater. The bank let client data reach a single person, who promptly destroyed it. The consortium, by contrast, is combing through 15 million internal documents, client data included, and publishing parts of them. Once again, nobody asked the clients.

Material for shareholders

In fairness, some of it is relevant to investors. For example, the question of whether the bank should have disclosed a 1 billion euro gap in its cost target in 2021. Or why the management board decided on a major write-down on port operator Maher Terminals in 2014 only after a capital increase. The bank denies having concealed anything.

That is legitimate business journalism. But it requires neither the names of private clients nor a global crusade.

The Vaduz hack

For the Swiss financial center, the revelations are unwelcome. Deutsche Bank runs a good part of its international wealth management business out of Zurich, and this is also where the sensitive Russia business was booked. But beneath the surface lurks another, larger risk. And it has to do with data held not by a bank, but by the state.

Liechtenstein learned this summer just how vulnerable such data collections are. In the night to July 30, unknown attackers broke into the Register of Beneficial Owners (VwbP) and copied data on around 31,000 legal entities (finews.com reported). The data includes names, dates of birth and nationalities of the people behind companies, foundations and trusts.

Since October 1, the Swiss federal government has also kept such a register. The Federal Office of Justice's transparency register records who stands behind Swiss companies (in German). It is not public, and data security is the top priority, Bern assures (finews.com reported). Calls from the asset management industry to postpone the launch after the Vaduz hack went unheeded.

Who's next?

It doesn't take a prophet. A central register listing the owners of hundreds of thousands of companies is an ideal target for hackers and whistleblowers. And it will find eager buyers, as this Tuesday shows.

We'll go out on a limb and say: The likelihood that the data already stolen in Vaduz will sooner or later go the way of the Deutsche Bank leaks is not small.